By Daniel Margrain
![]() |
Mirror Man (1971) | Captain Beefheart And His Magic Band |
Mirror Man showcases The Magic Band at it’s most deliberately shambolic and free. Long ‘live’ primordial rambling jams extend the notion of the Blues standard to its limits. Structurally, Beefheart (Don Van Vliet) and his band game-play in the Delta-Blues tradition adding satirical and infantile elements over a creative carpet of complex rhythms and free Blues arrangements. The result is an extraordinary work of pyrotechnical brilliance. With its combination of a bedlam of guitars and tribal percussion, Mirror Man was the first rock album to shape an aesthetic of ‘anti-music’. Beefheart’s revolutionary artistic vision transcends the superficiality of the acid trip by servicing it to the musical theatre of the absurd. As one critic put it:“This music is the most faithful expression of the Freak culture, of its marginalization more than its rebellion, of its inexhaustible creativity, of its academic disgust, of its infantile ferocity of its desecrating vision of the world” |
top marks for ‘ Pink Moon ‘ and ‘ Tonights the Night ‘ . I’d personally go for ‘ Veedon Fleece ‘ , ‘ Common One ‘
LikeLiked by 1 person
whoops sorry posted before I finished … was saying some great choices ( ‘ PInk Moon ‘, ‘ Tonights the Night ‘ , and ‘ Mirror Man ‘ which other than ‘ Doc at the Radar Station ‘ is the only Beefheart album I still possess at the age of 50 and I recall David Thomas saying was the only Magic Band album he really gets on with that much . ) – I’d choose ‘ Common One’ ,’ Veedon Fleece’ or ‘ No Guru , No Method , No Teacher ‘ myself out of Van Morrisons output .and though I possess two thirds of Zappa’s catalogue the ‘ qualities’ if one can refer to them as such – of ‘ We’re Only in it for the Money ‘ have eluded me for thirty years …. OK a few studiously hip lyrics that show he’s into what young people were talking about in California in 1967 and a cool Sgt Pepper spoof sleeve , ….but the music itself ? … uh yeah well maybe you had to be there . I mean once you’ve heard ‘ Bow Tie Daddy ‘ once why on earth would you ever feel the need to hear it again ? . To me this is the biggest dud in the mans principle ( pre death ) output along with ‘ Apostrophe ‘ and ‘ Waka Jawaka ‘ . .
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for your thoughts, Timothy – very interesting. There is much merit in your comment. That’s the great thing about music, its so subjective. I’ll be posting part 2 in a few hours.
LikeLike
thanks for your gentlemanly reply Daniel : much appreciated
LikeLike
final comment … as much of a Neil Young obsessive as I am …and as fond as I am of it – there’s a great Pitchfork review of ‘ Tonights the Night ‘ which accuratley describes it as often the sound of a bunch of raucous knuckleheads having the time of their life . You have to come this record expecting something a little different from the rest of Neil’s output . It’s described as ‘ dark ‘ but that’s more a comment on it’s lyrical themes …..’ Freedom ‘ by comparison is really musically dark and ‘ Tonight ‘ lacks the pensiveness might one say of the man’s most penetrating work . I still kind of wish we could have had ‘ Everyone Knows this is Nowhere ‘ re recorded by the Neil of 1990 . Ahh.Dreams !
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was fortunate to have seen Neil in Paris as part of his current tour. It was a brilliant show. We didn’t get Revolution Blues but I guess you can’t have everything.
LikeLike